Shannon Column: If I only had a hammer
Published: September 24, 2009
Now I know why people bring their hammer to Comcast offices in a last-ditch effort to improve their customer experience.
You may recall how 75-year-old Mona Shaw suffered a botched cable and phone installation at her home. Since she could not call Comcast to complain, she visited their office.
Told to wait outside in the heat, she did so for two hours until a staffer finally sauntered outside and told her the “manager” she needed to see had left for the day.
When Mona returned the next morning she brought her hammer and proceeded to get the attention of the entire customer “service” staff as she smashed keyboards, monitors and other assorted front
office equipment.
Mona struck a blow for beleaguered consumers everywhere. If FatHead.com sold her hammer-wielding image, I’d be first in line.
I’ve been thinking fondly of Mona during my latest voyage into the Comcast Zone. Late Monday night I sent out a newsletter and Sunday school update for my church — which shall remain nameless to
shield it from association with my many and varied sins. The list is 772 addresses long.
Tuesday, when Janet tried to reply to one of her Uncle Kenneth’s multi-forward humor-mails, Comcast blocked her reply. The error message suggested she visit http://www.youareinComcasthell.com and she
discovered we had been tried and found guilty of being spammers.
This might conceivably have been true in 1978, when there were only 600 e-mail addresses in all the world, but in 2009, when there are over 100 billion spam messages each day, 772 messages are not a
drop in the bucket — they don’t even qualify as water vapor wafting over the bucket.
What’s more, this is third time the net nannies have singled the Shannon family out for abusing the system. Each time it happens we are guilty until proven innocent and punishment is instantaneous.
When you call customer service to complain the response is always “the computer did it” as if this computer is some sort of doomsday system that humans are powerless to counteract. It would seem to
me that if the computer could render the sentence, it could also refer the appeal to a human who could look at the file and see it is just me and my church newsletter.
Spam accusations from Comcast are a kind of electronic hemorrhoid that flares up and grudgingly recedes. Even when the computer’s decision is reversed (minimum one hour on the phone) it takes 24-
hours of foot-dragging before service resumes.
But what really starts ball-peen thinking are the random, inexplicable insults you have no way of anticipating.
Recently Comcast treated Internet users to its new e-mail interface: “SmartZone.” A more accurate description would be “DeadZone.” During the transition from the old system to the new system
Comcast managed to lose my primary account and my son’s account. When I called to get that fixed, I discovered they would not talk to me because they had also corrupted my Social Security number.
After much angst the two deleted accounts were found, at the cost of Comcast technicians discontinuing my automated pay-by-credit-card. So while I was out of town Comcast cancelled our cable TV.
This is what’s so maddening about dealing with utilities that are quasi-monopolies “regulated” by the government. These behemoths are too big to fail and to incompetent to please.
Human repeat offenders suffer consequences. You do hard time. Family members wonder if you were someone’s boyfriend in the joint. And when you get out, the only company that will hire you is Metro.
But commercial repeat offenders simply employ more lobbyists to capture the regulators. While the customers are bounced from indifferent gatekeeper to gatekeeper until you finally find one who takes
pity on you.
If I was a Democrat this is where I would demand legislation, hearings and more government regulation. But I’m no longer a Democrat, because I’ve never encountered a situation that’s improved by adding
bureaucrats.
Instead, I’m considering practicing what I preach and encouraging competition. If we had e-mail portability like we have phone number portability, I’d be flagging down the nearest Verizon man and ridding
myself of Comcast and Judge Computer.
In the meantime, here I sit, surrounded by corrupted account data, branded with a scarlet “Spam” on my forehead, contemplating a switch of Internet providers. If this was a musical, I’d burst into song,
possibly sung to the tune of “If I Had a Hammer.”
If I had a hammer,
I’d hammer on their keyboard,
I’d hammer on their modem,
All over this land.
I’d hammer out vengeance
I’d hammer out a warning
I’d hammer out the hate between the customers and Comcast
All over this land…
Michael R. Shannon is owner of MANDATE: Message, Media & Public Relations, located in Woodbridge. He can be reached (for now) at .
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
I know I’m the outsider here, but we have had comcast for years and have never had a problem. They were always on time and my bill has never been wrong. When we moved we did sign up for satellite tv, and had problems with that from beginning to end so we switched back to comcast. If verizon ever comes to my area I might try it but right now I am happy with comcast.
Awww man, I really wanted to side with Michael Shannon on this issue and tell my story but with my limited vocabulary and the restrictions placed on posted comments:
“•Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
•Respect others.“
I won’t be able to say much without danger of being ostracised or maybe even jailed so I’ll just let Michael Shannon’s words speak for me. Thanks Michael.
Get Verizon FiOS when it comes to your neighborhood. Competition is a good thing.
oh and sorry Ron, my bill have never been incorrect…I hope that remains the case.
ha ha ha ha great letter, and now people want the same government that watches over COMCAST to watch over our health care ha ha ha ha ha ha
btw…I has COMCAST for years, got so sick of the constant rate increases, I went to Satellite. Then 10 1/2 months ago I was angry that VERIZON had dug up my/the county’s property to install FIOS, I was aggravated but I decided to switch away from satellite to Verizon because their (satellite) HD was having too many problems. I LOVE MY FIOS, I have had NO problems with it, and I have never been happier with my tv, internet and my home and cell phone service. My tv is great and never goes out, my internet is zippy and my home phone no longer has that buzz. And NO I do not own stock in VERIZON
I Can’t believe I’m actually in agreement with Mr. Simpson (AKA: OpinionWriter), but I guess it had to happen someday…
However, after shifting from ComCast to Verizon, I discovered their customer service and billing system is actually much worse. I took out one of their $89.99 per month triple play packages, and have had problems from the start.
My account was setup two weeks later than the date the sales people committed to. No amount of calls to Verizon could resolve it, and the customer service people claimed they were not responsible for what the sales department committed to.
Then, my first bill was $200 instead of the $89.99. The (un) helpful Verizon folks suggested it was just a first month billing error which would be straightened out “next month.“
“Next month” my bill was $500. After two hours on the phone during my work day, and after a bout of cursing at the rep, she finally claimed my problems were resolved. The next month my bill was $580 dollars. At this point, I filed a complaint with the FCC as the sole agency charged with regulating long-distance carriers.
Despite the Conservative’s contempt for government as the solution for any problem, my complaint did get results. About four weeks after I filed my complaint, a Verizon rep called me and explained that the issue was resolved.
Regrettably, I am stuck with Verizon for another year and eight months on this contract.
Comcast is heinous.
To let you in on something they failed to tell you … it’s not that you were “singled” out. Comcast blocks all emails that have more 20 plus recipients. After many hours on the phone troubleshooting this someone finally confessed that this is policy. I asked if there was a way to get switched over so that I could forward emails to a list of 50 or 100 people – nope.
I pointed out to the senior support member I was talking to that while Comcast management may find it inconceivable that people have more friends and family than where they top out (somewhere around 15) the fact remains that others in the real world do.
Verizon’s DSL service doesn’t restrict customers to 20 email addresses per message.


Advertisement